dreamstime_l_126555782

Managing Data Exchange Formats in the Context of Trade Document Processing: Middleware or a Universal Standard?

Dec. 5, 2023
While the appeal of a universal standard might be evident, the nuanced benefits of specialized middleware solutions and dedicated APIs shouldn’t be overlooked.

By: Chris Ciesielka, Orbweaver's Co-Founder and CEO 

Data exchange formats provide the means by which independent trading partners are able to recognize and utilize each other’s data. However, over time, the misinterpretations and misuse of these data exchange formats have allowed conformity to drift from a single and unified interpretation. 

Data Exchange Formats and Trade Document Processing
You may be in the process of either attempting to establish new digital integrations with external trading partners or addressing perceived deficiencies or inconsistencies within already existing integrations.

Transactions in the electronics industry are complex, with numerous operations involved in multiple business processes, from component manufacturing and distribution to system design and device manufacturing. In this context, data plays a vital role in unifying these operations towards a progressive outcome. Streamlined data exchanges are necessary for ensuring operational efficiency, maintaining accuracy and safeguarding profitability. A few examples include:

Sales and marketing: Data exchanges provide the platform for marketing and sales teams to engage with customers more effectively. Sharing product information in real-time helps customers make informed decisions quickly, improving efficiency and building trust.

Procurement: In the electronics industry, the procurement process is more than just purchasing components; it’s about making strategic decisions that impact efficiency and profitability. Buyers often face the task of locating the exact parts they need when they need them at competitive prices. By seamlessly sharing data about component specifications, availability, lead times and pricing, businesses empower their customers to make informed choices. 

Supply chain and logistics operations: Confirming orders, invoicing and sharing delivery confirmations are all critical processes in the industry. These activities rely on seamless data exchanges to function efficiently. When a customer places an order, prompt confirmation using accurate data ensures transparency. Proper invoicing minimizes disputes and aids in smooth financial transactions. Moreover, timely sharing of delivery confirmations with the necessary details helps businesses manage expectations and plan ahead.

Diverse data exchange formats play a significant and distinctive role in the electronics industry’s sales and procurement processes. Each format has advantages and challenges and is suited to particular types of tasks and transactions. The multitude of data formats isn’t just a consequence of technological evolution but a reflection of changing business needs and operational challenges. 

Common Data Formats in the Electronics Industry Supply Chain

FORMAT

DEFINITION

PROS

CONS

BEST USED FOR

CSV

Text file format that uses commas to separate values

Simplicity; easy to work with

Lack of hierarchical structure

Simple data interchange requirements with tabular data

PDF

Organizes data into a fixed layout for visual consistency

Consistency across platforms

Not suitable for automated data extraction

Sending invoices, reports and other non-interactive documents

EDI

A standardized format for structured and automated transactions

Efficiency and accuracy when properly implemented

Complexity; need for specialized management

Large and recurring B2B transactions

XML

A mark-up language for encoding documents in a human and machine-readable format

Represents complex data structures

Requires more processing resources

Complex data interchange requirements with a need for a hierarchical data structure

JSON

Lightweight data interchange format that humans and machines can work with

Easy integration

May not be suitable for highly structured or tabular data

Web-based applications, APIs and web services

As businesses began adopting solutions and applications that use and generate data in digital formats, structured data communication channels became necessary. Electronic data interchange (EDI), for example, emerged as a reliable solution, streamlining B2B transactions by mitigating paper-intensive processes. However, with the growth of new versatile digital solutions, formats like XML and JSON have gained prominence.

The CSV format is a versatile tool for efficiently managing relatively simple data exchanges. However, when faced with complex, hierarchically structured data, specialized formats such as XML and JSON are more apt. Their design inherently accommodates layered information, which is required in complex B2B transactions.

The choice of a data format transcends mere data storage—it’s intrinsically linked to functionality. While the PDF format excels in presenting information in a visually coherent manner, it’s not necessarily optimized for automated processing. Conversely, JSON has found favor in scenarios necessitating human-machine collaboration, particularly in API integrations and web services.

Digital integration with a trading partner may be described as an ETL (extract-transform-load) process, in which data is extracted from one trading partner in their desired file format, transformed via a data exchange standard, and then loaded by the other trading partner in their desired file format. In this operation, best practices depend highly on a robust and structured transform process.

As previously mentioned, over time, the misinterpretations and misuse of these data exchange formats have allowed conformity to drift. It is critically important not to emulate these unique instances within your normalized internal data storage. 

For example, the use and interpretation of qualifiers in EDI easily lend themselves to misinterpretation. Let’s say your customer uses the qualifier “CB” (“Buyer’s Catalog Number”) as opposed to the more standard “BP” (“Buyer’s Part Number”) to identify the part they are buying. You already have buyer_part_number as a data element in your data store; does this mean that you should create buyer_catalog_number as well? In most cases, the answer is no. Regardless of the name or identification of data by your external trading partner, data should be normalized in your system with emphasis given to how the data is used and what it means to your organization.

This presents two challenges, both of which should be resolved in the transform process of data exchange and should not be recorded within your normalized internal data store.

  1. When returning an order confirmation to the customer, you need to use their qualifier to reference their data.
  2. In constructing the returned order confirmation, you need to recall what unique non-standard qualifier that trading partner used.

The data used and required by the transform process should be stored outside of your internal data store. Failure to manage data in this way will prevent an organization from effectively scaling digital solutions.

A Universal Standard vs. Industry-Specific Middleware
Addressing complexities in data exchange formats is a pressing concern. While a unified standard might seem appealing, a deeper examination reveals potential pitfalls. Introducing a new overarching standard might not simplify our challenges as anticipated but could introduce added complexity. This is because every format in use was designed to meet specific requirements. Attempting to merge them could yield a compromised standard not fully optimized for any particular need.

The way forward is leveraging technology instead of chasing the elusive dream of a new standard. It’s far more pragmatic to focus on cloud-enabled middleware solutions which act as vital links, facilitators and conduits, ensuring streamlined data interactions.

Given the varying data formats and the challenges they pose, businesses must utilize digital tools that specialize in data normalization. These tools are crucial in bridging discrepancies between data formats and ensuring efficient interactions. Coupled with robust APIs, consistent and industry-specific data normalization provides the agility and efficiency needed for successful data exchanges. This approach stands as a more pragmatic and sustainable alternative than initiating an effort to develop yet another new, overarching standard.

It's essential to keep in mind the significance of each data format. Be it an invoice, a purchase order or shipment details, each piece of exchanged data has a distinct business function. The success of these data exchanges—and their subsequent influence on business operations—largely depends on the chosen format. Here, APIs play a pivotal role. They function as connectors in the digital framework, ensuring smooth integration and clear communication across different systems and data formats. They are adept at translating, interpreting and ensuring that data, no matter its source format, is transmitted in a comprehensible and usable manner.

Although the prospect of creating a unified standard might appear logical, it holds the potential to further complicate the existing landscape. The focused utilization of digital technologies for data normalization, fortified by effective, industry-specific APIs, has become a realistic and efficient way forward. This approach ensures smooth and standardized communication across different data exchange formats regardless of the purpose, increasing operational efficiency and reinforcing industry collaborations.

Although the data exchange landscape in the electronics industry may seem intimidating, the path forward is clear. The answer is not to move all organizations to a single standard but to allow your data management processes to seamlessly interpret all existing standards by harnessing the power of industry-specific middleware and robust APIs like the ones developed by Orbweaver.

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Supply Chain Connect, create an account today!